Where was God when that happened?

A book about tragedy 'did not resonate with my world and the regular, and almost daily, conversations I have with people in an acute hospital'

Where was God when that happened?
By Christopher Ash
The Good Book Company
ISBN: 9781910307236
Reviewer: Derek Fraser

This is a book with a title to catch the eye. It poses a question that few escape asking. Its presentation is in short bite size pieces. Its author has had pastoral experience over a number of years. He considers a variety of approaches to address the issue and provides seven ways that might be used to engage with the issue.

While the question of why suffering is a complex one, it is one that many have written about from a variety of theological positions. This author takes a very strong position around the concept that God is in control and builds his ideas almost exclusively on that. He goes so far as to posit that God governs over evil, God uses Satan as His instrument and that God directs evil powers. “God decrees that all manner of things shall happen, including evil things,” he writes. He controls and directs evil.

Fundamentally I was left feeling this book was flawed in its thinking and it comes across as pastorally disconnected from people. It lacks connection, compassion and a clear place for prayer, pleading and ways of living faithfully in the face of suffering.

It is not enough to simply stress the theoretical and cerebral aspects of this issue that God is in control. There needs to be an engaging pastoral dynamic shown so people connect with the ideas proposed and the solutions offered. The book was cold comfort, combined with tortuous logic and one I would not want to recommend, least of all to someone struggling. The quoting of scriptural passages in a dip and pick manner to support a theological theses is not to grasp and present the authentic voice of scripture. It did not resonate with my world and the regular, and almost daily, conversations I have with people in an acute hospital.

A finer and more pastorally engaged book would be John Swinton’s Raging with Compassion. He blends scripture, life and pastoral sensitivity into a superb book that deserves careful attention.

Baptist minister the Revd Dr Derek J Fraser is Lead Chaplain at Addenbrooke's Hospital

Baptist Times, 09/02/2018

Post Tweet

A Calendar of Carols by Gordon Giles

'A useful, well-researched tool for those who want to know more about how the carols we sing came about - but would have benefitted from some illustrations'

Wounded I Sing: From Advent to Christmas with George Herbert, by Richard Harries

Devotional reading helps us avoid the too-soon collapsing of Advent into mere preparations for Christmas - and here Harries demonstrates how George Herbert is our most significant observer of the spiritual life through poetry

Do Not Be Afraid, by Rachel Mann

'In this Advent book Mann writes with a simplicity that conveys a depth of wisdom both scriptural and theological, and which is related to the ordinary things of everyday life'

The DNA of Healthy Discipleship by Dave Criddle

'Accessible, rich in insights and practical wisdom, this is a book for anyone who is serious about following Jesus and helping others to do the same – and just wants to get on with the job'

Jesus and the Powers by Tom Wright and Michael F. Bird

Rather than telling Christians how to vote, the authors focus on the relationship of God’s Kingdom to the powers that govern different countries and to democracy