Logo

 

Banner Image:   National-News-banner-Purple
Template Mode:   Baptist Times
Icon
    Post     Tweet

John Humphrys’ Programme on Benefits Breached BBC Rules

A BBC television programme that spoke of a ‘benefits dependency culture’, breached the corporation's own rules on impartiality and accuracy.

The BBC Trust was largely supportive of The Future of the Welfare State, presented by John Humphrys and broadcast on BBC 2 in October 2011.

However it found that viewers were  ‘left unable to reach an informed opinion’ because of a lack of statistical information, and had misleading statements about benefits spending. The programme therefore breached the BBC’s guidelines on accuracy and impartiality.

The programme emphasised the view that a 'benefits dependency' culture has grown up, with people happy to remain out of work and living off benefits. In an accompanying article in the Daily Mail Humphrys, a presenter on the Today programme, wrote, ‘'Beveridge tried to slay the fifth evil giant and, in the process, helped to create a different sort of monster in its place: the age of entitlement'.

The complaint was made by the Child Poverty Action Group. Its chief executive Alison Garnham said, 'This programme, like too many media stories, failed the public by swallowing wholesale the evidence-free myth of a "dependency culture" in which unemployment and rising benefit spending is the fault of the unemployed.’


The Joint Public Issues Team of the Baptist Union of Great Britain, Methodist and United Reformed Church has attempted to highlight the myths surrounding poverty in the UK through its Truth and Lies report and subsequent campaigning on the issue.

It has called on both the Government and media to stop misusing statistics and misrepresenting the most vulnerable.
 
    Post     Tweet
New Brian Haymes book launched
Contributions and Struggles: Some Theological Contributions brings together a selection of Brian's essays and sermons, edited posthumously. It launched at a thanksgiving service for Brian's ministry and life
Liverpool parade crash: 'Appalled and saddened'
Churches leaders in Merseyside shared the following statement and prayer in the wake of the incident that injured crowds celebrating Liverpool's Premier League title win on Monday
‘We can choose to tell a new story – one of gracious growth’
​General Secretary Lynn Green urged Baptists to embrace a story of hope and renewal rather than decline in her closing address at the Baptist Assembly
ba25report
'God's Baptist people are in good heart' - Steve Finamore's reflections
Outgoing Baptists Together President Steve Finamore shared encouraging signs of church growth and renewed hope across Baptist networks
ba25report
More than 60 ministers and pastors commissioned at Baptist Assembly
Ministers who have transferred to the fully accredited list, nationally recognised pastors and recognised local ministers were commissioned and prayed, in a session which also featured the In Memoriam
ba25report
Mission Resolution introduced at Assembly
Designed to build a shared understanding of mission across Baptists Together, this marks the beginning of a two-year process of discernment, dialogue, and engagement, with the goal of the resolution being adopted at the 2027 Baptist Assembly
ba25report
     Latest News 
    Posted: 04/06/2025
    Posted: 21/05/2025
    Posted: 07/01/2025
    Posted: 07/01/2025
     
    Text Size:  
    Small (Default)
    Medium
    Large
    Contrast:  
    Normal
    High Contrast